Shanghai's Best Restaurants: City Weekend Readers' Choice Awards
2,200 CW readers voted for their favorite Shanghai restaurants. These are your winners.
Best Thai: Simply Thai
Simply the best Thai food. Shanghai voters made their voices clearly heard as Simply Thai took home 30 percent of the ballot box. All four locations feature a flavorful menu of classic and seasonal Thai dishes like vibrant Tom Yum soup, piquant glass noodle seafood salad and papaya salad. They frequently offer great deals on food in their inviting restaurants.
First Runner-Up: Coconut Paradise
Editor's Pick: Naam Thai
Best Wi-Fi: Element Fresh
In this close race, decided by just 30 votes, you, our always-on-the-go, plugged-in readers, have spoken on where you go to get that Wi-Fi fix. This chain keeps you connected from early in the morning to late at night, making itself a cornerstone for Wi-Fi refugees. Take note: the Kwah Centre location turns off its Wi-Fi during lunch hour (1-3pm) to keep the crowd moving.
First Runner-Up: Wagas
Editor's Pick: Citizen Café
Best Business Lunch: Jean-Georges
There’s something about dark wood, plush leather chairs, those square plates and an expansive Bund view that says "Shanghai power lunch" to
17 percent of readers. World-class food and service deserving of the Jean-Georges name for just RMB188 (noon-2:30pm) doesn’t hurt either. Get your power suit pressed–it’s time to close a deal.
First Runner-Up: Enoteca
Editor's Pick: Allure (Le Royal Meridien Shanghai)
Best Value: Wagas
This health-conscious chain secured the top spot with nearly 27 percent of the vote due to their quality food, large portions and willingness
to accommodate even the pickiest eaters. With half-off breakfast and post-6pm pasta discounts, it's no wonder that Wagas gets rave
reviews on our website. User strawberrysays declares: “Count me in, I'm there!”
First Runner-Up: Noodle Bull
Editor's Pick: Brasil Steakhouse
Best Spicy: Di Shui Dong
After being knocked from its spot at the top of Shanghai's spicy fare royalty last year, Di Shui Dong is back where its throngs of followers say it should be: at number one, with a solid 24 percent of the vote. In reviews you usually comment on the service and the décor, but for Di Shui Dong, those come in a far second to the food. Actually, why kid ourselves? It’s all about the ribs. User tristamarie’s comment says it all: “On a recent trip, we devoured quite possibly the best spicy Hunan spareribs around leaving nothing but bone and a few wayward cumin seeds on the plate.”
First Runner-Up: South Beauty
Editor's Pick: Sichuan Court
Best Chef: Francesco Greco (Palladio)
The Milan-born chef of the Palladio restaurant (The Portman Ritz-Carlton) still holds sway over local diners with signature dishes that people return again and again for. In the fierce battle for Chef of the Year, Greco beat out Willy Moreno (El Willy) by one percentage
point.
First Runner-Up: Willy Moreno (El Willy)
Editor's Pick: Emmanuel Souliere (Leonardo’s, Hilton Shanghai)
Best Italian: Da Marco
This inconspicuous, wallet-friendly Italian stallion is back in the top spot for the third year in a row with 27 percent of the vote. Though down from its peak of 32 percent of the ballot box last year, Da Marco is still highly rated throughout Shanghai's dining world. It even gets four out of
five stars from Dianping.com users too.
First Runner-Up: Otto
Editor's Pick: Danieli's (St. Regis)
Best Mexican: Cantina Agave
Although the battle for best Mexican restaurant feels like it has been raging for ages, 2009 marks the first year there have been enough restaurants in Shanghai to warrant this highly contested category. Readers have spoken and Cantina Agave, with its casual "Cali-Mex" concept, won by 54 votes over MAYA's upscale, Latin fare.
First Runner-Up: MAYA
Editor's Pick: El Mexicano
Restaurant of the Year: MAYA
Quality Mexican cuisine is all the rage in Shanghai so it’s no surprise that Shanghai readers have crowned MAYA as king of the restaurants. They captured 18.3 percent of the ballots and squeaked out a win by 24 votes. Under the culinary direction of Chef Brad Turley (who reportedly has a local farm grow hard-to-find chilies for him), MAYA’s tables are consistently packed with diners feasting on delicious tilapia fish tacos, scrumptious sopes and delicate snapper ceviches. The famous churros and well-mixed margaritas are musts.
First Runner-Up: El Willy
Editor's Pick: M on the Bund
Best American: Element Fresh
This incredibly popular expat dining institution easily dominated this category for the second year in a row, winning 31 percent of the
vote. With fresh and hearty helpings of sandwiches, smoothies, salads and an American-style brunch fit for a king (we love The Big American), this über-healthy chain is a great alternative to typical American greasy spoons.
First Runner-Up: Boxing Cat Brewery
Editor's Pick: Blue Frog
Best Hotel Dining: Tables
Tables at The Portman Ritz-Carlton won this battle with its combination of intriguing décor and sumptuous food. The restaurant features table tops made of different materials–marble, mother of pearl, mosaic, bronze and gold leaf–and serves classic pan-Asian favorites like Hainan chicken rice and spicy laksa.
First Runner-Up: VUE Restaurant (Hyatt on the Bund
Editor's Pick: JW’s California Grill (JW Marriott)
Best Japanese: Haiku by Hatsune
As one of Shanghai's culinary heavy hitters, this Japanese restaurant simply will not be denied its number one spot. Last year Haiku won City Weekend Readers' Choice Awards for "Best Japanese" and “Restaurant of the Year." This year they repeat in the Japanese category, capturing 29.2 percent of the vote. After nearly three years in the business, this California-style sushi restaurant remains one of Shanghai’s "it" places for tasty, creative rolls and is consistently one of the highest buzzed restaurants on the City Weekend website. User and Haiku devotee utensils1977 explains, "I'm going back there for the hundredth time this Friday and I can't wait to sink my teeth into the Moto-rollahs." You can take utensils1977's suggestion, or opt for more traditional favorites like the Spider or Dragon rolls. Or, give your taste buds an adventure with one of our Haiku favorites: the 119 Roll–a new twist on the good old spicy tuna roll.
First Runner-Up: Shintori
Editor's Pick: Sun with AQUA
Best Wine List: Palladio
Named after renowned Italian architect Andrea Palladio (1508-1580), Palladio at The Portman Ritz-Carlton offers a wining and dining experience that is a true work of art. Palladio's wine selection includes over 450 bottles of wine from every corner of the world. Whether you’re looking for a sip of New Zealand Cloudy Bay, a casual chardonnay from Napa Valley or are planning to break the bank for a bottle of Louis Latour, you’ll find what you're looking for here. Sip your wine in peace (but don’t leave without trying the antipasti and carpaccio) while admiring the 17th and 18th century-style Palladian columns and arches as well as the romantic garden outside. It just goes to show, in the race for "Best Wines," even a great Bund view cannot beat an expansive and tasteful selection of the world’s best. Wine Spectator agrees, awarding Palladio the "Best of Award of Excellence" in 2004, 2005 and 2006 and the "Award of Excellence" in 2003 and 2002 for their wine selection.
First Runner-Up: Napa Wine Bar & Kitchen
Editor's Pick: Dining Room (Park Hyatt)
Best Family Friendly: Blue Frog
This repeat winner claimed a total of 284 votes, making it a clear favorite. Featuring a "Little Frog" menu, children’s play areas at the Jinqiao and Hongmei venues and a location in nearly every major suburban area, this highly-buzzed chain remains one of the city’s most family friendly dining destinations.
First Runner-Up: O’Malley’s Irish Pub
Editor's Pick: Bistrow by Wagas
Best Contemporary Chinese: Jade Garden
The glass panels, polished marble floors and cream-colored chairs of this top restaurant make you feel like you’ve stepped into a palace. Dianping users give the venue four and a half of five stars and high marks (23 of 30) for both taste and décor. Prepare for tea-smoked duck, wine-preserved crab and stir-fried river shrimp specialties that'll leave your taste buds singing for joy.
First Runner-Up: Crystal Jade
Editor's Pick: Southern Barbarian
Best Dessert: Whisk
With a perfect five buzz rating on the City Weekend website, it's no surprise Whisk won nearly 20 percent of the vote. This restaurant-cum-dessert café has a place in our hearts (and next to our sweet tooth). “Five stars for the quality and taste of the food and desserts," says user strawberrysays. "My personal favorite is the Chocolate Therapy. If something is getting you down, this slice of heaven will (if only temporarily) solve [the problem] for you. The cake is moist, flavorful and so rich. It comes with a generous portion of homemade whipped cream,
which is just the right amount of sweetness to offset the richness of the cake and fudge." Their chocolate chip cookies are some of the best around, but that's only if you can snag one–they run out of stock quickly. The venue has developed a reputation for not tolerating loiterers, so
if you're only there for a bite of dessert, keep it quick–or the staff will.
First Runner-Up: House of Flour
Editor's Pick: Bellagio
Best French: Jean-Georges
Three-star Michelin chef Jean-Georges Vongerichten’s outpost in Shanghai remains the restaurant to beat with 32.2 percent of the votes, despite hearty attempts by Franck and the promising Hamilton House. For another straight year, readers have been wooed by the expertly prepared, classic French fare and J-G’s reputation for excellence. Despite a change at the helm, er, in the kitchen that saw Eric Johnson pass the torch to Lam Ming Kin, his enthusiastic and affable executive sous chef, things haven't slowed down. Lam, a Hong Kong native, has been with Jean-Georges since its inception in Shanghai and has wasted no time in his new position, already putting his innovative take on the new spring menu.
First Runner-Up: Franck
Editor's Pick: Hamilton House
Best Outdoor Space: M on the Bund & New Heights
It’s poetic and statistical justice that these Bund staples which share the same iconic view, also share this award. Each earned 15.1 percent of the vote. Enjoy the view from M with a dessert platter. When at New Heights, Executive Chef Xavier Mauerhofer, suggests the crab salad with fresh basil, tomato jelly and balsamic reduction to go with your view.
Editor's Pick: Kommune
Newcomer of the Year: Cantina Agave
They came, they saw and they conquered. With 25 percent of the vote, Cantina Agave is your Newcomer of the Year. In November ‘08, Cantina
Agave appeared on Shanghai’s restaurant scene with a casual "Cali-Mex" dining concept offering luscious burritos for all. People seem
to have pretty strong thoughts about this venue whose CW online listing is a virtual comment war. Regardless, their delectable fish tacos, creative
salsa bar and packed margarita nights are clear winners in everyone's book.
- 10: The record number of hours a group of people has stayed for Cantina Agave's brunch and all-you-can-drink margarita deal.
- Chili: Cantina Agave uses seven types of imported chilies to create their awardwinning Mexican fare.
- Fact:Kelley Lee and Raffe Ibrahamian originally planned for Cantina Agave to be half of its current size. It also took them five months to settle on their Fumin Lu location.
First Runner-Up: MAYA
Editor's Pick: Osteria
Missed Shanghai's best nightlife people and venues? Check out the City Weekend Readers' Choice Award Winners here.
Comments Add a public comment
Most Recent Comments
-
-
-
-
I'd have to agree with Shanghai Chefs: http://www.shanghai-chefs.com/?p=463
-
-
Hey there,
I've seen the Shanghai Chefs blog as well. Since it's now linked here, I'll post my response as well. The following is a direct response to Alfred's (the author's) queries, but if you're looking for more information about our decision making, it might also be helpful.
Hi “Alfred”,
This is Joanne, City Weekend’s dining editor. As much as I respect the opinions of others in this industry, especially the chefs behind the food, I have to politely and personally disagree with your statements. Hopefully my response can provide some insight into our decision process and correct your misconceptions about our 2009 awards.
In response to: “But honestly, those editor choices really make me wonder if these Editors have any clue about what they write or if they even bothered to visit the places they chose more than one time; or was is just the one lunch they got invited to by the owners in order to review the place?”
and
“Stop trying to please all the restaurants you go to”
I believe that no one in F&B media is so insensible as to believe that the quality of food served during a meal with the owner is the same as another regular diner would get.
That’s why all our reviewers make a concerted effort to go, as regular diners, to all the restaurants we write about. City Weekend DOES NOT base our awards decision on advertising clients, or as you say, the people who have treated us to a nice lunch. If you take a look at our magazine, you can see that Masala Art (EP best Indian) or Hamilton House (EP best French) have never purchased ads. Osteria, our choice for Newcomer of the Year, is a restaurant my columnist and I both frequent and admire for having good food at affordable prices. We definitely understand that not every person may agree with this choice, but this award is one that Osteria earned by having consistently good food and appealing atmosphere—it is not a sales-driven selection. Everyone, the editorial staff at CW included, obviously had different opinions on who was the best fit, but Osteria was one of those rare restaurants where every one of us had had a great dinner.
In response to: “If you keep the Editors choice please let us know the criteria involved”
A restaurant can be chosen as editor’s choice for several reasons—sometimes they’re venues that are just out of the race by a few votes but are still super popular with readers, or they’re newer restaurants that are good but haven’t developed much of a following yet, sometimes we’ve just had a train of good experiences at certain restaurants, on the job and off, and feel secure in recommending these venues to others, etc. There is a panoply of reasons really. What all the EPs have in common is that I’ve always consulted two or three and sometimes four other diners about the choice to get a bigger sample of dining experiences before I make my decision.
Lastly, I agree that Shanghai has a huge range of restaurants, many undiscovered—and I’d welcome any of your suggestions for restaurants you think we should check out. Share the wealth! As a Shanghai born girl, I also think Western restaurants are really just the tip of the iceberg and am working to include more local features in the Dining section.
Thanks for making the effort to constructively critique the awards and the magazine. I don’t agree with all of the expressed opinions, but I do appreciate that you took the time to tell me what you’d like to see in this section so we can make it that much better.
Cheers, Joanne
-
-
Thanks for coming on and offering an explanation Joanne. While I'm not sure you fully address all of the complaints - particularly the self-contradictory nature of the Editor's Note and why Editor's Picks are included in the first place - at least you have come on to defend your decisions.
Naturally, there will always be a difference of opinion on these things and that's partly the beauty of it. I do not think however that only allowing voters to choose from a list of restaurants that you yourselves have nominated and then throwing in Editor's Picks should be trumpeted as "transparent" and as a shining light of openness. Patting yourselves on the back for being so fair and balanced seems a little hasty given that you chose a format that was always going to be open to allegations of bias - however accurate they may be.
Also, having read that Shanghai Chefs post about it all, i totally agree that a bit of criticism now and then wouldn't hurt. Too often CW copy (in general) reads like slightly reworded press releases.
On a different note, i'm glad to hear you're planning on ramping up the local restaurant coverage. Too much attention is paid to semi-average Western restaurants in place of some brilliant local options
-
-
In response to mansizerooster83's comment:
"I do not think however that only allowing voters to choose from a list of restaurants that you yourselves have nominated"
Actually, every category allowed voters to write in a vote for any venue that was not nominated. We carefully reviewed and counted all of the write-in votes in addition to the nominated venues.
-
-
I can only infer by the above comments that each candidate restaurant for an awards category is visited several times to ensure that it is fairly represented. Restaurants can have an off night and give a bad experience, and on the other hand there are some unscrupulous restaurant owners who will lavish free drinks and food on reviewers to try and get a better review.
If CW is in fact visiting all restaurants equally, my compliments -this must take an incredible amount of time and money (as one can't honestly give an objective critique of a meal that wasn't paid for).
Judging by the above comments, several staff visit a chosen restaurant on several occasions. In the interests of fair play, I must ask: How many times was each restaurant visited to determine an 'Editor's Choice Award'?
-
-
Hi Micky,
Just saw your comment :) I make an effort to go at least once by myself and I also get opinions from other diners who have gone to the restaurant as well as my colleagues in the industry. So there is no standard number of times each EP restaurant is visited, but my personal rule of thumb is at least once, though I've gone to a good number more often.
-
-
I've been in Shanghai for almost 10 years and dine out virtually every night as a bonafide foodie. I totally agree with some of the food picks and respectfully disagree with some others. However, I just want to point out a couple curiosities that stand out.
1) How does Maya win Restaurant of the Year while not even finishing 1st in its own categories of Best Mexican or Best Newcomer? Seems a bit strange and doesn't really jive... Hard to justify this one. An odor of ballot-stuffing perhaps? The sad fact is that readers only vote for the few restaurants that they actually visited.. which means the frame of reference is sorely lacking. Not to belittle the survey, but it would be more transparent and helpful if you also reveal the number of votes actually garnered by the winners and runners-up.
2) Why are all of the Editor's Picks different from the Reader's Choices? Each and every single EP doesn't even correlate with a 1st or 2nd place Reader's Pick. I noticed this is also true with the CW issue ranking the best bars and clubs. This doesn't make any sense. Seems that either CW's editors are totally out of touch with the real pulse within the F&B scene or they're making efforts to accommodate more names and places than is necessary.
I understand that each person has his/her own tastes and opinions, especially when it comes to food or drink. However, the apparent contradictory nature of the results certainly tests the integrity and legitimacy of the survey. I do hope that the next dining survey appears more impartial and consistent than this one.


In the magazine, the Editor's Note talks about an e-mail from an unsatisfied reader and says:
So as a response to a complaint about restaurants being unfairly nominated, you, err, nominated some restaurants? For good measure, you even threw in some Editor's Picks. Doesn't seem all that transparent