The most accurate title for Henry Kissinger’s new book might be something wonky like On the Perception of the International System Among the Elite Chinese Leadership. On China has a more commercial ring to it though, and when you pick up a volume by Kissinger, the living ghost of America’s post-WWII foreign policy establishment—with the Coke-bottle glasses to prove it—we can’t be expecting the People’s History of the People’s Republic.
Nonetheless, with a title as sweeping as this, we’d expect Kissinger to make an effort to represent “China” as more than a monolithic entity. It’s a mistake commonly made in the foreign media, as if a nation of 1.3 billion were a single actor with a single purpose and worldview. Readers interested in Chinese views of diplomacy should pick up this hefty work, but those hoping for a gripping memoir should look elsewhere.
The book, Kissinger says, is “an effort … to explain the conceptual way the Chinese think about problems of peace and war and national order.” Despite a review of historical Chinese attitudes to outsiders, he’s mostly talking about a very select group of senior Communist Party officials with whom he’s brokered important diplomatic agreements over the last 40 years.
A sweeping view of China in all its complexity is not what we want from Henry Kissinger. His personal involvement in U.S.-China relations is what makes this book potentially important: few statesmen have been handed such decisive opportunities to shape international diplomacy as Kissinger when he first went to China in 1971 on a secret visit. The most exciting promise of this book is an up-close look at the events leading up to those historic first meetings in Beijing, and an insider’s account of what occurred there.
Kissinger the historian dominates Kissinger the memoirist. After the preface, we wade through 212 pages of background and analysis on the historical factors shaping Chinese diplomacy before Kissinger finally speaks in the first person. This is where it could get exciting, but Kissinger, even as he describes his early visits with Mao and Zhou Enlai, still often sounds more like a scholar than someone who was actually there.
An exception is when he describes his poignant final visit with Zhou Enlai, who had been sidelined by illness and politics: “Our dialogue never reached an exchange of personal comments,” says Kissinger. Surprising, considering that others have called the two friends. Still though, Kissinger says, “I consider it an honor.” Kissinger compares Chinese diplomacy to the game of wei qi, known in the West as Go. For example: “Chess produces single-mindedness, wei qi generates strategic flexibility.” The choice of metaphor is telling. For Kissinger, the line between strategic games and real-life war and peace has always been thin—his favorite board game is actually called Diplomacy—and his attempts to implement strategy on the ground have often been disastrous and, arguably, in violation of international law. With On China, though, he reinforces his worthiest achievement for posterity. We can only hope that lasting peace between the U.S. and China continues to speak for his efforts.
On China is available on Taobao for RMB238 plus RMB12 shipping.
The conspiracy theorist angle is that Kissinger got too deep into black ops ("backroom dealings") of which details are sealed for another 50yrs. Very much similar (like Britain's secrecy codings) to Churchill's WW2 1939 decision to let the "Fortress of the East" Singapore fall to the Japs as a strategic decision that had been sealed till the late 90s.
So considering the depths of Kissinger's involvement -- it could well be the details files are sealed for 75yrs (or more). So hang around folks for another half a century or so... as the "Truth is out there". :-o
:-) That's a great quote, Narfs; you sure you did use to work for the a Transport Ministry before? ;-)
Other Posts by This Writer
Book Review: The Fat Years by Chan Koonchung
By shepherd
Well, it looks like Western capitalism will last through the end of the year, after ...Book Review: The Fat Years by Chan Koonchung
By shepherd
Well, it looks like Western capitalism will last through the end of the year, after ...The East Is Fed: Beijing’s Revolutionary Restaurants
By shepherd
On October 1, the People’s Republic of China celebrates its 62nd birthday. It’s the perfect ...Backyard Café’s Roasted Veggie Salad a Healthy Hit
By shepherd
Sometimes when we’re deciding where to eat, we find ourselves craving a veggie fix. We ...Book Review: Aerotropolis by Greg Lindsay
By shepherd
Schools, sports and leisure facilities, high-end hotels, logistics, housing and even (limited) nightlife options have ...Singledom in Beijing—What Gives?
By shepherd
Last spring, the Penghao Theater presented “RENT a White Guy: The Musical,” about an average ...Paul French Re-opens a Murder Case in Old China
By shepherd
Early on the morning of January 8, 1937, a rickshaw driver noticed something odd at ...Is Free Wi-Fi in Beijing a Thing of the Past?
By shepherd
In late July, café and bar owners in Nanluoguxiang were summoned to the Jiaodaokou Police ...By shepherd
Singaporeans are serious about their laksa, a spicy fish and noodle soup that, it seems, ...Book Review: Olympics Redux for Beijing Welcomes You
By shepherd
Each time a Westerner produces a memoir or travelogue set in China, the Chinese come ...By shepherd
So Beijing isn't exactly the country where one can enjoy numerous varieties of fragrant, ripe ...The Man Behind the Coolest New Liquor Shop in Sanlitun
By shepherd
Liquor lovers in Sanlitun aren't exactly spoiled for choice, but Zan Xiaohu's new bar/shop Heaven ...Touring Beijing's Three Revolving Restaurants
By shepherd
America’s romance with the revolving restaurant peaked in the 1980s. But it’s another story in ...Cool Off With Madame Zhu’s Ice Cream With Tofu
By shepherd
For a refuge from the summer heat, it’s hard to beat Madame Zhu’s Kitchen. We ...Will Expats of Today Be China’s Pensioners of Tomorrow?
By shepherd
There’s good news and bad news. The good news is that starting July 1, foreigners ...Could a Violent Attack Happen to You in Beijing?
By shepherd
In early June, the Global Times reported on a 30-year-old woman who was attacked at ...Louis Vuitton Goes From Past to Present in "Voyages"
By shepherd
The new National Museum of China recently rolled out the red carpet for “Louis Vuitton: ...Will Revelers Ever Drink Again at Beijing Rock Fests?
By shepherd
Around 4pm on the first day of the Modern Sky Beijing Strawberry Festival, an unexpected ...Will Beijing’s Latest Smoking Ban Stick?
By shepherd
On May 1, another government ban on smoking in public places took effect throughout China, ...Book Review: Aerotropolis--How Airports Are Shaping the Future
By shepherd
Urban planners in Amsterdam have a saying: “The Airport leaves the city / The City ...
Kissinger describes everything in this book in terms of Wei qi: Chinese Diplomacy is like Wei Qi, The mountainous regions have to be traversed like a difficult opponent in the game of Wei Qi, The infighting between political opponents in The Party is like a game of Wei Qi, This cup of tea tastes a bit like Wei Qi, Nurse, so you have my Wei Qi handy? I think I've just had an accidental Sei Qi in my underpants. Joking aside, I expected more from someone who is regarded as a Titan of diplomacy. This book reads more like a sad monologue of someone concerned mostly with writing a book that sounds like a .... sad monologue.