We're always wondering what life is like for our friends back home. Here resident LGBT writer, Adam Frost, compares issues facing the LGBT community in the East and West.
If you’re reading this, then–unlike me–you haven’t flown the coop for the summer and are enjoying the perks of a Shanghai summer, like never having to iron your clothes because a) the humidity makes the wrinkles fall out and b) you aren’t wearing clothes anyway. I’m currently travelling through the States to beat the heat, visit friends and check out how the gayers are doing on the other side of the Pacific.
In my travels, I’ve been talking with old friends and meeting new people, and it made me wonder how different gay life is in America from China and what our “family” overseas think gay life is like in Shanghai.
Tim Brown, a gay American I met for the first time on this trip who has travelled overseas (but never to Asia), had a rather dreary outlook on how gays live in Shanghai. “I imagine it’s very closeted and underground,” he said. As we talked, he was impressed by the development of the gay community in Shanghai, but skeptical about how positive life could be given the prejudices gays often face–especially where gay lifestyle is so nascent.
Mike Smith, an old friend and wingman who has also travelled abroad but has yet to bring himself to visit us in China, simply stated, “I’d stick out like a sore thumb because I’m so tall.” At 188cm he might be right, but a walk onto a basketball court at any school might leave him surprised by a generation raised on a calcium-rich diet and a healthy appetite for the NBA.
For a different perspective, I chatted with a gay netizen from Chongqing who visited Japan as a student. He wasn’t sure how different gay life was overseas, only noting that gays can marry in some foreign countries. He was curious about how gays live in other countries and seemed geniunely interested in expanding his horizons.
My background and upbringing will always color my opinions of Shanghai, but after five years here I think I can claim a certain amount of insight into our differences. I have to admit that what I’ve seen is that the differences aren’t as broad as people think.
Gays in the East and West don’t seem truly to understand each other, but our underlying goals and interests are very similar. We want to enjoy our lives with friends and lovers. We want acceptance and safety in our lives. At the moment in many Western countries, it seems that marriage is the definition of true acceptance in society. As homosexuality becomes mainstream in China, Chinese gays are starting to think similarly to their Western friends, which begs the question: how long will it take?
Want to weigh-in on the debate? Share your opinions and experiences here.
Other Posts by This Writer
By adamfrost
PRIDE is once again upon us so here’s the official rundown of what will be ...Shanghai's Gayest Gyms: Where Shangays Are Getting Fit and Fabulous
By adamfrost
I spent most of the winter working my way through DVDs (the werewolf on BBC’s ...Sobering LGBT Polls Across Asia Highlight the Need for Pride
By adamfrost
According to a recent poll by the Friendly Taiwan Alliance, which was subsequently reported by ...It's All In the Eyes: How to Navigate LGBT Style in Shanghai
By adamfrost
Stereotypically, the men will be thin, immaculately dressed and coiffed, the women burly and swathed ...Save the Date: The Latest on Pride and Other LGBT Events for 2012
By adamfrost
I recently sat down with Shanghai LGBT maven and Shanghai Pride organizer Charlene Liu to ...The Bars in Shanghai that Swing Both Ways
By adamfrost
Bars have long served as an important meeting place for folks of a certain persuasion, ...We're Asking: Where Is the Gay Literature in Shanghai?
By adamfrost
With the Shanghai Literary Festival in town, my editor me asked me, “What do gays ...Gay Valentine's Day: Suggestions for Shanghai’s Gay Singles
By adamfrost
Valentine’s has never been my holiday. I’ve spent any number of Feb. 14s with friends ...Am I Gay? What to Do if You’re Questioning Your Sexuality
By adamfrost
I vividly remember my first childhood crushes. From the athletic Greg Louganis in the ’88 ...How Has Shanghai's Gay and Lesbian Scene Evolved Over the Last 10 Years?
By adamfrost
The Chinese gay scene was really born 10 years ago when homosexuality was delisted as ...New Years, New Queers: A Look at the LGBT Scene for 2012
By adamfrost
As a community, Shanghai LGBTers have accomplished loads, so I’m looking forward to a bright ...By adamfrost
Shanghai's hetero meat market has outlets all over town--a nightclub here, a cocktail bar there. ...By adamfrost
Of all the wonderful flavors that Shangays come in, the hardest to define is bi. ...Sex Toys for All the Girls and Boys
By adamfrost
Shanghai is the merry-go-round of China. There are always new people getting on and getting ...Kissing Controversy: Gays in the Military
By adamfrost
What is it about a uniform that elicits such interest? I’m not talking about your ...Shanghai Pride Week Kicks Off this Weekend
By adamfrost
The dates have been set; the venues have been arranged and it looks like it’s ...Man Seeking Shanghai: Finding LGBT Options in China
By adamfrost
Same-sex daters in Shanghai may occasionally be heard complaining about the lack of options for ...Here, Queer and Online: The Best LGBT Websites
By adamfrost
Gays are everywhere, so it’s no surprise that a myriad of websites exist out there ...LGBT Scene: Using Prejudice for Gain Shouldn’t Be an Option
By adamfrost
It seems like only yesterday I sat at Starbucks on Hengshan Lu interviewing Ricky Lu ...Shanghai Pride Festivals On The Horizon
By adamfrost
Pride season is upon us. The weather is getting warmer, the rains will finally die ...
Hi Adam! I´d really like to get in touch with you. I´m a student of journalism in Shanghai to work on an article about the situation for gay people living in rural China vs. in urban China, with regards to tolerance, openness, obstacles, discrimination and so on. You seem to have a lot of insight and interesting thoughts about the situation in Shanghai. If you could email me on torahope@gmail.com, I´d be very grateful! Best regards!